Skinny Yoked: In Pursuit of Lean Mass
best shaker bottles compared

Shaker Bottle Showdown: 5 Best Blender Bottles Reviewed

Unless you’re a caveman you’re probably not getting all your protein and nutrients exclusively from whole foods.

The average bodybuilding is consuming more powder than the entire real characters of Wolf of Wall-Street combined.

From pre-workouts to intra-workouts and post-workout protein blends it seems we’re constantly having to mix something.

shaker rack

For you, choosing a bottle will come down to the following:

  • You need to mix pre-workout or protein or both?
  • How viscous will your shakes be?
  • How much powder do you need to fit in?
  • Do you need to store pills/other supplements as well?
  • Are you a lazy washer or meticulous cleaner?
  • What’s your budget?

By narrowing down your needs you should be able to find what you need from the above list. You don’t need to limit yourself to just one bottle either, sometimes two tools can get the job done better than just one!

Top Performing Mixer Bottles of 2020 Reviewed

It seems like only yesterday the original Blender Bottle with the steel whisky ball started appearing on shelves everywhere from supplement shops to even Wal-Mart.

best blender bottle

Since then, partially thanks to the growth of bodybuilding and partly the incessant promotion of supplements, shaker bottles have slowly been evolving.

No longer are you stuck with an old old water bottle or Nalgene and clumpy ass nasty half-mixed pre-workouts and protein shakes. No, now there are a whole variety of dope shakers of all sizes and offering multiple functions.

protein overload

The humble shaker bottle has evolved from just a regular bottle with a agitator to a practical swiss-army knife supplementation delivery tool. Here are the 5 coolest shakers currently on the market:

1. The Classic Blender Bottle

Blender Bottle, the company, has expanded impressively beyond it’s humble one-bottle beginnings. They now make a whole variety of bottles and storage devices for fitness fanatics like us.

BlenderBottle Classic Shaker Bottle, 28 oz, Black
29,408 Reviews
BlenderBottle Classic Shaker Bottle, 28 oz, Black
  • 28-ounce capacity (note: measurements only go to 20 ounces) shaker cup for mixing protein shakes, smoothies, and supplements
  • Patented mixing system uses 316 surgical-grade stainless steel BlenderBall wire whisk found only in BlenderBottle brand shaker bottles
  • Screw-on lid creates leak-proof seal, and flip cap snaps securely shut to keep contents contained; loop top for easy carrying or attaching keys
  • Wide mouth makes it easy to add mix scoops and liquids, and embossed markings measure both ounces and milliliters

The Classic Blender is our favorite because why mess with a good thing? Cap screws on quick and easy and doesn’t require much fuss and never leaks.

The whisk is a simple design that works well and the plastic is BPA free. We don’t know what BPA is but we’re glad it’s not in there?

For the the more serious bro who ain’t f*cking around they make the Prostak bottle and sell a modular Expansion Pak add-on so you can carry all your powders, pills and weed stash with you all in one package.

BlenderBottle ProStak 22 Oz Bottle with 6 Piece Twist n’ Lock Storage Set, Black
269 Reviews
BlenderBottle ProStak 22 Oz Bottle with 6 Piece Twist n’ Lock Storage Set, Black
  • Expands the capacity of the BlenderBottle ProStak shaker cup to hold large protein, meal replacements, powders, supplements, and more!
  • Unique BlenderBottle ProStak system interlocking jars with individual lids make it possible to carry supplements, snacks, and more, with or without the bottle!
  • Includes one one 250cc jar, two 150cc jars, two 100cc jars, and two Twist 'n Lock pill storage trays
  • Compatible with any Blender Bottle Pro Stak shaker cup system / Leak-proof SureSeal flip cap, secure screw-on lid and loop top

The fully built-up Prostak w/ Expansion Pak is one impressive device. Granted it’s probably a bit much for a quick drive to your local gym, it could definitely be handy if you have to squeeze your gym time in before/after work and don’t have time to go home and mix pre-workouts, protein and supps separately.

The Prostak is definitely not to be f*cked with:

2. The Hydra Cup Dual Shaker

The Hydra Cup is another “all-in-one” kind of shaker bottle that does more than just mix one liquid. Instead, utilizing two separate chambers and two separate drinking holes,

Hydracup allows you to have your two blends at the same time.

This is sweet because even with the above Blender Bottle Pro, if you mix your pre-workout and keep your protein in the bottom for post workout, and you don’t have a place to wash it out, then your chocolate whey post workout will probably have the same taste as your watermelon pre-workout.

Maybe this is a good thing? Maybe not. We’re not sure, but we are a little OCD and thus keeping our liquids separate is a pretty cool thing.

The two compartments aren’t just limited to liquids however, as advertised, you can put mid-day snacks in there like nuts, you can put ice in there, or like we a dime bag and a one-y, whatever!

Only question is, because of the shape, there isn’t any “agitator” unit in the liquid to help blend it together, just a plastic grill on the top to filter out any clumps.

So we probably would only use Hydra Cup with proteins that we know don’t clump together like a bunch of little turds (we’re looking at you Mass Gainers).

Still, brands like Rogue Fitness and Musclepharm have both licensed/offer branded versions of the Hydra Cup so you know it’s got to be solid.

3. Mous Shaker

The Mous shaker was a Kickstarter project that didn’t get funding but went onto production anyways. Why? Well because it’s a beautiful design solution to a problem everyone faces.

mous shaker review

The goal of the Mous Shaker is to eliminate that rotting protein smell most shakers get when they aren’t washed thoroughly or they ARE washed but bits of protein stay in the corners at the bottom of the bottle or in the grooves in the lid.

So to eliminate all the places where protein powder could get stuck they made the vessel rounded, so no edges for sh*t to get stuck. They also made a lit with only one groove to keep that from getting gunked up to.

mous lid

The result in the quest to remove all possible opportunities for stank to develop? Well, an utterly beautiful shaker that we’d love to take to the gym to show off because it’s so damn futuristic looking.

4. Cyclone Cup

The Cyclone Cup is no slack either. Continuing with the “multi-purpose” shaker trend, the Cyclone Cup has a cool little stash compartment at the bottom for your powders, cash, or whatever you want to put in there.

The really cool thing about the cyclone cup and what makes it unique is the cone-shaped fixed agitator. Most other shaker bottles utilize a free-range agitator that bounced around inside the bottle to help mix powders. Others don’t have agitators and instead use a flat grill at the mouth of the cup to strain chunks.

The Cyclone Cup on the other hand uses a hybrid filter that protrudes INTO the blend.

We think this is really cool because sometimes with really thick shakes, like mass gainers that use milk instead of water, and have chia seeds mixed in or double doses of protein powder, the super light-weight wire whisk ball has a tough time really cutting through the thicker liquid.

This is where a fixed place cone agitator would really come in handy; mixing the f*ck out of especially thick shakes.

cyclone shaker colors

Additionally, like many other manufacturers they are offering a dope selection of colors. It’s a cool product, in cool colors, with a unique blending feature. We like it.

5. Umoro One

Last but certainly not leas we have the Umoro One. This is probably one of the funnest shakers to use because of it’s cool “push button release” function.

Essentially, you preload a little container with your supplement  and then when you want to mix it just push a button to drop the agitator and powder into the water/milk below.

Umoro definitely gets points for creativity here. The big problem they’re solving with this “push button release” technology is sometimes, if you’re on the go and your put your powder in your standard shaker and add liquid later the powder will get stuck in the bottom and even the agitator won’t be able to free it.

The downsides of the Umoro is because it’s so engineered it has it’s limitations, as you can only fit one big scoop of powder in the lid.

This means there’s no issue with pre-workout or BCAA supplements but if you’re used to two-scoops of protein you won’t be able to fit it all. Still, using something like a high protein whey isolate should help you pack in enough protein.

Despite the quantity limitations and extra sharp corners (this shaker is the absolute opposite of the Mous shaker mentioned above) the build quality is very solid and BPA-free, which is very important for long-term health.

*Bonus Special Honorable Mention*

#6 Jaxx Metal Shaker Cup

We had to include the Jaxx Metal Shaker Cup because it really is a very well built shaker; it’s made of stainless steel for Pete’s sake!

While they do make plastic cups just like everyone else, the Jaxx Stainless steel cup is the one you want to get.

There’s no denying the long lasting and oder-fighting benefits of having a protein shaker made out of stainless steel.

Additionally the Jaxx uses a unique agitator that looks like, you guessed it, a jax to help mix powders.

Fit & Fresh Jaxx Stainless Steel Shaker Bottle,with Patented Jaxx Agitator for Smooth Protein Shakes, 24-Ounces
195 Reviews
Fit & Fresh Jaxx Stainless Steel Shaker Bottle,with Patented Jaxx Agitator for Smooth Protein Shakes, 24-Ounces
  • STAINLESS CONSTRUCTION: Shaker bottle is made from durable 18/8 food grade stainless steel
  • NO CLUMPS: Patented Jaxx agitator easily and powerfully mixes protein powder and supplements for smooth shakes every time
  • COMFORTABLE TO HOLD & CARRY: Ergonomic design with removable handle that you can clip to backpack or gym bag
  • PERFECT SIZE: Convenient size, holds 24 ounces, measures 8" X 4.5" X 4.5"

Besides just looking cool the Jaxx agitator is actually weighted, so like we mentioned previously, if your bulking or just really like mixing really thick shakes, having a fixed agitator (like the Cyclone Cup) or a weighted agitator like the Jaxx cup will really help you mix up fluids with higher levels of viscosity.

We also like the huge (oversized) carrying handle which comes in handy when you got your hands full with things like your iphone, towels, belts and wraps.

The Skinny Yoked Summary

There you have it, 6 awesome shaker bottles to suit all needs and all occasions. If you need something to carry your bottle and gym gear, check out our recent roundup of “The Top 7 Meal Prep Gym Bags“. Personally, if we had to choose a #1, best shaker bottle on the market we’d probably go with the original Blender Bottle, partly because we’re purists and enjoy simplicity, and partly because we feel the original always deserves the most respect.

It will be interesting to see how manufacturers can continue to push the evolution of the humble shaker bottle, if it’s still even possible at this point.


Last update on 2020-09-27 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Comments (22):

  1. Mark Hicks

    September 14, 2018 at 9:49 pm

    Not to be rude but this post was pretty long. If you just had to recommend one shaker bottle as the “best all around” option which would it be?

    • Virgie Smith

      September 14, 2018 at 10:00 pm

      It’s all good. I wanted to review all the options out there to help people make more informed purchasing decisions. To answer your question though, the best overall cheap option would be the BlenderBottle classic. They are cheap and last forever.

  2. Jose Taylor

    September 15, 2018 at 7:52 am

    Which one is best in terms of being able to store stuff? I want a bottle that I can mix my protein but also stash my supplements in.

    • Benjamin Fuller

      September 15, 2018 at 8:10 am

      In terms of storage compartments your best bet is either the BlenderBottle ProStak 22 oz.

  3. Dollie M.

    September 16, 2018 at 4:38 am

    What is the best BPA-Free option? I want something I can use for a long time without worrying if I’m being slowly poisoned or something.

    • Christine M.

      September 16, 2018 at 4:54 am

      Hey man! Most bottles are BPA-free but if you want to be 100% certain you’re shaker cup isn’t hurting you then you need to go with either glass or steel materials. This means either the Mous shaker or the Jaxx metal shaker.

  4. Matthew Hayes

    September 17, 2018 at 2:56 am

    Great post, appreciate the review as it’s hard to find honest feedback from a real bodybuilder!

    • Hannah B.

      September 17, 2018 at 3:15 am

      Glad to help bro!

  5. Juan Martin

    September 18, 2018 at 12:58 pm

    Is the Hydracup Dual Shaker really practical or is it just some kind of marketing gimmick?

    • Martha K.

      September 18, 2018 at 1:14 pm

      Personally I only bring protein shakes to the gym, so having two sections is a bit redundant. My friend however who travels a lot for business loves his Hydra because he can pre-load it with preworkout and protein which works great for hotel/hotel gym living without a kitchen to mix stuff separate.

  6. Madge Smith

    November 25, 2018 at 3:10 pm

    Where is the cheapest place to buy a blender bottle?

    • Erik Bowitz

      November 25, 2018 at 3:37 pm

      Definitely online, you can always find them on sale just do a Google search. If you don’t want to wait Wal-Mart and Target stores usually have them on sale regularly as well.

  7. Lester Gordon

    November 27, 2018 at 9:38 am

  8. austin

    November 27, 2018 at 12:23 pm

    All I care about is how easy/hard my bottle is to clean, I hate getting clumps stuck in crevices that I can’t get out!

    • Erik Bowitz

      November 27, 2018 at 12:30 pm

      I hear that. I find the classic Blender Bottle is one of the easiest to clean long term. It’s worth getting a scrubber brush on stick (like a toilet bowl cleaner) as well if you drink shakes daily as it makes cleaning deep down much easier.

  9. teresa

    November 28, 2018 at 10:51 pm

    I don’t like drinking out of plastic.. it wears and just doesn’t seem safe. What are my other options?

    • Erik Bowitz

      November 28, 2018 at 10:58 pm

      Blender Bottle makes a stainless steel bottle (Radian line) and a glass bottle as well. The metal one is $25 and is insulated as well so you can use it for more than protein shakes as well.

  10. harriett

    November 29, 2018 at 7:31 am

    Great post! Thanks for lining all these options up, I had no idea there were so many mixer bottles out there!

  11. Ella Barber

    November 29, 2018 at 12:04 pm

    Prostak for life. Had mine over 2 years now and haven’t had a problem yet!

  12. Leonard M.

    November 29, 2018 at 3:04 pm

    Lost my whisk..what do I do?

    • Erik Bowitz

      November 29, 2018 at 3:20 pm

      You can order replacement whisk balls on Amazon or direct from the manufacturer of your bottle.

  13. Lucinda Swanson

    November 29, 2018 at 11:48 pm

    Great read, thanks for digging into what makes all of these different by comparing and contrasting to find the best deals. Time to do some shopping!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *